In the sentence "You forgave me my mistake" are there two direct objects or is one a direct object and the other an indirect object? — Min Kyung Jun, South Korea
A direct object is the person or thing that directly receives the action or effect of the verb. It answers the question "what" or "whom." An indirect object answers the question "for what," "of what," "to what," "for whom," "of whom," or "to whom" and accompanies a direct object.
In the sentence "You forgave me my mistake" the thing being forgiven is the mistake, so "my mistake" is the direct object. The mistake is being forgiven for me so "me" is the indirect object.
This sentence has an added confusion because the direct object of "forgive" can sometimes be a person (me) and sometimes be something that is wrong (my mistake).
In the above example, the direct object of "forgive" is something that is wrong. Below is an example of the direct object of "forgive" being a person:
In "She forgave Sam for ruining the party" the direct object is "Sam" and the indirect object is "ruining the party."
Sometimes the direct and indirect objects are more obvious, as in the examples below:
He threw the ball to Sam. [He threw what? The ball. To whom? To Sam.]
She gave the phone to her mother. [She gave what? The phone. To whom? To her mother.]
Other times it is less obvious which noun is the direct object and which is the indirect object, as in the examples below:
He threw Sam the ball. [He threw what? The ball. To whom? To Sam.]
She gave her mother the phone. [She gave what? The phone. To whom? To her mother.]
We asked them a question.
I read the baby a book.
In all of the above examples, the indirect object comes before the direct object, but when you ask the questions "what is thrown" (the ball), "what is given" (the phone) "what is asked" (a question) and "what is read" (a book) the answers will tell you which noun is the direct object.
I hope this helps. For more posts about words, idioms, grammar, and usage, like us on Facebook and follow us on Twitter!
Don't forget to subscribe to our Word of the Day e-mails!
Click here to try one of our vocabulary quizzes before you go!